Hospital and Doula Care Integration in the Obstetric Setting: A Qualitative Study
Received: 04-Jul-2026 / Manuscript No. jpch-26-193352 / Editor assigned: 06-Jul-2026 / PreQC No. jpch-26-193352 / Reviewed: 20-Jul-2026 / QC No. jpch-26-193352 / Revised: 25-Jul-2026 / Manuscript No. jpch-26-193352 / Published Date: 31-Jul-2026
Abstract
Introduction: We sought to understand patient, provider, payer, and doula perspectives on integrating doulas into the obstetric care team within hospital systems. Methods: We conducted and examined 34 semi-structured qualitative interviews with 12 postpartum women of color, 11 clinical providers, 1 payer, and 10 community doulas. Results: Our study found 1) there is needed collaboration between doulas and providers for the benefit of patients at highest risk; 2) some misconceptions and biases exist between these groups; and 3) logistics to improve obstetric patient care should be analyzed and remedied at the systems level. Conclusion: Pregnancy doulas, birth workers who support pregnant people and connect them with resources, are becoming normalized as part of the care team during the prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum periods. Our results emphasize the need to integrate doula care within and beyond hospital systems.
Keywords
Doula; Hospital systems; Maternal health
Introduction
Pregnancy doulas, birth workers who support pregnant people and connect them with resources, are becoming normalized as part of the care team during the prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum periods. Marginalized patients, such as patients of color in obstetric settings, are disproportionally affected by negative health outcomes with Black patients often voicing that they are not communicated with appropriately in the hospital setting.[1] Doulas and other birth workers have been shown to improve certain birth outcomes including preterm birth and cesarean deliveries.[2-4] Birth workers have been involved in obstetric care for centuries; however, there is a lack of understanding to practically and consistently integrate doulas into current obstetric care due to the increasing complex health care delivery and payment environment. Our qualitative interview study aimed to understand the perceived drivers of maternal health disparities and inform the early development of an integrated doula-based model of care. Given the current research on doulas within maternal healthcare equity, it is important to explore the factors that both alleviate maternal health disparities but could also lead to issues with implementation at later stages of doula models of care.
While there is needed collaboration between doulas and health care delivery teams for the benefit of patients, especially those at highest risk, there are misconceptions and biases between these groups, and a lack of understanding of the optimal approach to integration. Our objective was to understand patient, provider, payer, and doula perspectives on integrating doulas into the obstetric care team –as this understanding is critical to achieve maximal effectiveness of future equitable care.
Materials and Methods
We conducted qualitative, narrative interviews with four groups: postpartum mothers, clinical providers, a healthcare payer, and community doulas. A total of 34 semi-structured qualitative interviews with 12 postpartum women of color, 11 clinical providers, 1 payer, and 10 community doulas were completed. The interviews were conducted over the phone, lasted from 30 to 60 minutes, and were transcribed by a third-party service. Interviews were completed and analyzed by the study team, who all identify as researchers with one community doula partner included as well. The interview guide ranged from asking questions about understandings of disparities for birthing people of color to the ideal model of care for the pregnancy continuum. Postpartum patients were identified using the electronic medical record (EMR). Snowball sampling, sampling through participant connections, was used to identify participants who were community doulas, physicians and payers. Providers were from one urban hospital system while doula interviews were obtained with the guidance of an author and contributor of this study who is a community doula and founder of a 501(c)(3), Black-owned, maternal resource platform, designed to support Black & brown moms in 3 key stages: Pregnancy, Postpartum & Compassion. Informed consent to participate in the study was obtained from all participants. Each patient and community doula received a $75 gift card for their participation. The transcripts were cleaned of identifying information and coded using NVivo software. Two transcripts were open-coded, and a codebook was developed from the emerging themes, using an integrated approach. Two researchers used the codebook to complete inter-rater reliability tests on 25% of the transcripts, to reach agreement on all codes (κ > .75). Thematic saturation was reached, and major themes were identified after member-checking.
Results
Our study population included patients of color who delivered at a large, urban health system and were anywhere from four weeks to six months postpartum (n=12), providers at the health system (n=11), 1 case manager from a payer, and community doulas (n=10). All 12 patients identified as women, 11 self-identified as Black, 1 selfidentified as Asian, and 11 had government-funded insurance. Of the providers, 10 were physicians and one was a nurse practitioner. The interview themes illuminate that providers and doulas share similar attitudes around their understanding of health outcomes disparities, support needed for their patients, and composing an ideal model of care for birthing patients. We found that 1) there is needed collaboration between doulas and providers for the benefit of patients at highest risk; 2) some misconceptions and biases exist between these groups; and 3) logistics to improve obstetric patient care should be analyzed and remedied at the systems level.
Collaboration between Doulas and Providers for the Benefit of Patients at Highest Risk
When discussing the role of community support for birthing people, participants across all three groups of patients, providers, and doulas expressed positive views. The doulas interviewed shared their perspectives on what the role of a birth support worker should entail. Many expressed the belief that the role should involve providing and directing clients to resources, ensuring their needs are consistently met, and being someone mothers can lean on for help and guidance. However, most doulas emphasized the need to customize their approach to meet specific patient needs.
“You have to know your client and have an understanding of who they are.”
The majority of providers expressed their belief that all patients should have a birth support worker or doula with them during their pregnancy and delivery journeys. They outlined that the role should involve emotional support, assistance with breastfeeding, advocacy, and birth education. Many providers who discussed advocacy and patient education emphasized the importance of ensuring patients are heard by their physicians and providing true informed consent. They also highlighted the doula’s role as a mediator to improve the relationship and communication between the care team and the parent.
“There is potentially a role to serve as another person checking in with the patient, making sure that the communication has been good between the patient and their providers…Maybe the doula can have a level of comfort with the patient, especially if there's some cultural concordance about what some barriers might be then bring them to the provider's attention.”
More than half of the mothers interviewed reported that they had not interacted with any birthing support workers. Among this group, one participant mentioned being offered birthing support by their physician but did not receive follow-up. Others stated they were never offered doula support. For those participants who had experiences with birthing support workers or doulas, each described it as a positive experience. They mentioned tasks such as purchasing baby items, providing breastfeeding support, attending appointments, and answering questions.
Many providers underscored these patient views with their own understanding of the important and impactful work of doula care, saying, "It wasn't just this like random provider running and being like, ‘You need to do this right now,’ because the doula already had trust with the patient and was- and they were also understanding of why we were doing it.”
When mothers were asked about their perspectives on the role of birthing support, they echoed similar sentiments to providers. Common themes included assistance with resource navigation, education about birthing and pregnancy, and having someone available for regular check-ins. They expressed the desire for a supportive presence who could offer both educational guidance and emotional support.
“Somebody to give encouragement were needed. Even if you need to cry like a little baby, somebody will hold you. Somebody that's going to be there with absolutely no judgment and you don't find it in the healthcare industry as often as you used to anymore.”
Overall, patients, doulas, and providers felt the presence of birth workers in obstetric care as important aspects of overall wellbeing.
Misconceptions and Biases
Both doulas and providers had previous misconceptions about each other's ability to help pregnant patients beyond general amicability. Participants from both groups of doulas and physicians expressed concerns about potential barriers doulas might face within hospital settings, mirroring challenges and obstacles encountered by clinicians. Obstacles mentioned included the quality of the relationship between the doula and their client's providers, challenges in accessing resources for clients, and the general public's lack of awareness about doula care.
Providers reported varied experiences with doulas, with many characterizing their experiences as generally positive despite some mixed encounters. One nurse explained when working with a doula,
“It wasn’t negative at all despite the stereotype that was fed to me. It was a very positive experience.”
In cases where providers had negative experiences, they perceived that doulas were overstepping by offering feedback on medical advice instead of focusing solely on providing support and facilitating improved communication. Instead, they felt the doula created awkwardness rather than bridged gaps.
One provider shared a story where the doula disagreed with their plan for the patient’s care. Upon returning to the room, they found that the patient had changed their mind, leading the provider to speculate that it was influenced by the doula's dissatisfaction with the plan.
“The goal is to have the discussion all together and to have the discussion where we're all able to express …as a provider, the recommendation and my sense of why it's my recommendation. When a big part of that conversation happens once I've left, then it's a little hard to feel like we're all working together.”
Many physicians expressed a preference for doulas to remain as support persons and allow the physician to handle the clinical aspects of care, which trained doulas agree on generally and historically already. One provider recounted a negative experience with a doula and their role in the birthing process:
“They feel like their role is to just fight with us. And it's frustrating, because by definition, they are not trained or capable to actually do our jobs. We are. And so, it's really frustrating having someone who you know doesn't know anything about how to do your job, try and tell you what to do and be wrong and be argumentative. It was like she was trying to find a role, prove that she was important or that she was necessary in a way that was just really, really unnecessary, off putting, aggressive.”
However, many providers shared positive experiences they had with doulas, highlighting the valuable role they play in caring for birthing people. In one interview, a provider praised the way a doula could empathize with the patient and fostered a trusting relationship while remaining attentive and considerate.
“I remember distinctly [there] was this woman who was actually really incredible. She was Black, the same race of the patient. It was the doula who really was more explicitly explaining things in a way that the patient could understand.”
Doulas also shared varying experiences with physicians and clinical teams in the hospital. While many described positive relationships with providers and care teams, highlighting instances where providers were “open-minded” to doula care and treated them as integral members of the team, others recounted negative experiences stemming from clinicians not respecting their role in the patient’s care. One doula recalled an encounter with a nurse where they felt their position was not respected saying, “This is my client just as much as your client.” Others noted that negative experiences often arose from clinicians disregarding patient preferences and disliking when doulas advocated for their clients. Interestingly, these sentiments align with some providers’ perspectives. For instance, one provider admitted to silently asking themselves, “Is this going to be a supportive or obstructive doula?”
Logistics to Improve Obstetric Patient Care at the Systems Level
When discussing ways to strengthen the relationship between doulas, hospitals, and clinicians, both doulas and providers expressed that improving familiarity between providers and doulas is key. Both doulas and providers discussed the potential benefits of integrating doulas more extensively into hospital systems to strengthen their relationship, yet many were also concerned about the logistics of this integration.
Participants in each group highlighted the importance of meeting beforehand about concerns, as for many, it is their first encounter, and establishing this connection early on would lead to a smoother collaboration. While doulas candidly addressed the existing negative perceptions, they advocated for creating spaces where doulas and providers can engage in conversations to reinforce their shared goals.
“Spaces where doulas can actually have conversations with providers to make sure everybody has a better understanding. Because honestly, I think just birth workers sometimes have a bad taste in their mouth about providers.”
Both doulas and providers discussed the potential benefits of integrating doulas more extensively into hospital systems to strengthen their relationship. Suggestions included hiring more doulas within hospitals, with one provider proposing a referral process for patients to access doula services. Another provider suggested finding some way to recognize doulas as part of the care team, even if they are not hospital staff, instead of providing them visitor passes. However, participants from both groups expressed concerns about potential barriers doulas might face within hospital settings. One provider, who had previously worked as a doula, voiced concerns about the potential for conflicts of interest when doulas are employed by hospitals.
“You would have to hire just as many doulas as you would with nurses because you have to be able to support them continuously… but if a doula is working for the hospital, it's a conflict of interest because her interest is for that patient and sometimes what the patient chooses or wants is in conflict with what the hospital wants.”
Doulas shared some barriers that they felt interrupted their ability to provide service and care to their clients including the quality of the relationship between the doula and their client's providers, challenges in accessing resources for clients, and the general public's lack of awareness about doula care. One aspect of this integration is making sure that doulas and birth workers are systematically and financially supported:
“The role of a birth worker is something that you really have to be sure that you want to do because there's no day off. There's no time off - it's really important because you're being trusted with someone in such a vulnerable time.”
When discussing the role of community support for birthing people, participants across all three groups expressed positive views. Many doulas highlighted the significance of structures such as peer support groups and educational programs in providing support within their communities. Mothers who discussed the role of community support highlighted the importance of local resources that assist with affordability and provide education, acknowledging that access to such programs would be limited without community support. Providers also emphasized the value of community care in addressing barriers like childcare issues or transportation challenges. They noted that receiving support from familiar faces in the community can often mean more to patients than support from healthcare providers they may not relate well to.
“It would be ideal to have them be from the community where there is already some trust because sometimes it's hard to have like a crunchy-granola white person try to come in and help someone who's Black and poor.”
Although there were some differences in approaches, each group agreed upon the inclusion and integration of doulas into the care team.
Discussion
Our study highlights the shared experiences and perspectives of birthing people, providers, and doulas regarding pregnancy, delivery, and postpartum care. Doulas and providers alike expressed a desire for shared understanding to improve relationships and ensure optimal support for birthing people. Previous qualitative studies have separately attempted to understand the attitudes of providers on doula care and vis versa [5,6]. Our methods and analysis attempt to put community doulas and providers from the same healthcare contexts into a cohesive story about the opportunities and issues of systematic integration.
While there were minor differences in perspectives within our interviews, there was a shared vision for prioritizing safety, health, and well-being throughout the pregnancy, delivery, and postpartum journey. All groups emphasized the importance of individualized care, consistent support, and ongoing advocacy for birthing people. As demonstrated in a prior study, patients who had birth support workers found the use of doulas during their pregnancy and beyond helpful overall for understanding and learning about their care [7]. These overlapping goals and actions as found in these interviews are promising for future integration between doulas and the clinical care team with a shared goal of providing optimal, equitable care.
It is important to take a systematic approach rather than individualized to solving issues of communication, biases, and historical divisions between providers and doulas [8]. Implementation of these dynamics is an ongoing issue including the importance of paying birth workers through payer systems [9,10]. Doulas are, therefore, seen as often underutilized yet valuable parts of solving the maternal morbidity and mortality crisis for pregnant people of color in the United States [11].
Previous literature confirms our findings that doulas, patients, and providers agree that communication between each group is key to better health outcomes, but that cultural competency between each group is also important [12]. For example, further work needs to explore not just training on the roles of each group, but also provide the history, cultural impact, and spiritual aspects of birth work” [13].
These cultural issues can also extend to the relationships between providers and doulas, with assumptions being made about gender, race, and class issues. The negative language used to describe community-based doulas in some of the provider interviewees is tied to the stereotypes about Black women generally standing up for their own healthcare needs or even the needs of others, leading to poorer communication with Black patients and their birth support workers [14]. These biases can lead to certain doulas being not understood or listened to by hospital staff, just like their patients [15,16].
Conclusion
Our study was limited to provider and patient interviews from one hospital who are often asked to think about maternal health equity. Other providers across the United States, as well as other members of the care team, may not share the same perspectives about experience and training, or notions about birth support and doula care. This study aimed to explore the attitudes of doulas, providers, patients, and payers around doula care in an obstetric, hospital setting, building upon previous work exploring the importance of doulas throughout care. Our results emphasize the need to integrate doula care within and beyond hospital systems and to evaluate the effectiveness of this deliberate, integrated team model on maternal health outcomes.
References
, ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
- Kathawa CA, Arora KS, Zielinski R, Low LK. (2022) Journal of Midwifery and Women's Health 67(1):31- 38.
, ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
- Gebel C, Larson E, Olden HA, Safon CB, Rhone TJ, et al. (2024) J Midwifery Womens Health 69:550-558.
, ,
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
, ,
- Campbell-Voytal K, Fry McComish J, Visger JM, Rowland CA, Kelleher J. (2011) Midwifery 27(6):214-21.
, ,
Citation: Burdick M, Gebru H, Doumbouya A, Mengesha M, Srinivas S (2026) Hospital and Doula Care Integration in the Obstetric Setting: A Qualitative Study. J Preg Child Health 13: 707.
Copyright: 漏 2026 Burdick M, et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Select your language of interest to view the total content in your interested language
Share This Article
Recommended Journals
Open Access Journals
Article Usage
- Total views: 232
- [From(publication date): 0-0 - Nov 18, 2026]
- Breakdown by view type
- HTML page views: 194
- PDF downloads: 38
